Is there room in hockey for a 2F-3D configuration?

As we await word on the fate of the 2020-21 NHL season, theScore is revisiting innovative ideas from different corners of the hockey world. Consider this four-part series food for thought during a most unusual offseason. (Part 1 is about replacing the draft lottery. Part 2 is about teams picking their own playoff opponents. Part 3 is about implementing an Exception Player Rule.)

––––––––––

Roughly a dozen years before he earned a role with an NHL team, you could find Jack Han punching orders into a cash register a few steps from one of professional hockey's most iconic arenas.

Han, now 31 years old but a high-schooler back then, helped with his parents' mobile fast-food stand near the Bell Centre on Montreal Canadiens game nights. Operated by Han and two cooks, the stand served burgers, paninis, and fries to passersby waiting for puck-drop. Following the rush, Han would hustle home to catch the game on TV.

"Working together in a commercial kitchen is really close to playing hockey," Han said in a recent interview.

In both environments, individuals simply can't fulfill their duties in isolation, he added. Everyone must be positionally flexible.

Courtesy Jack Han

Han - who worked in the Toronto Maple Leafs organization as an NHL video and statistical analyst for the 2017-18 and 2018-19 seasons and an AHL assistant coach in 2019-20 - often uses food to explain and describe his takes on modern hockey. The approach has come in handy of late, with his Hockey Tactics Newsletter gaining notoriety following a four-part series that detailed an eyebrow-raising deployment strategy.

The unconventional idea: Rather than the traditional three forwards and two defensemen on-ice configuration, coaches should consider deploying two forwards and three defensemen - 2F-3D for short - during five-on-five play.

Icing one fewer forward seems counterintuitive, especially since most power-play units across the NHL feature four forwards and one defenseman. In theory, though, 2F-3D would provide tighter coverage in the defensive zone, and a distinct "three backs" look in transition through the neutral zone and on the attack in the offensive end. It would also give coaches the freedom to divide ice time more appropriately among their top players, regardless of position.

However, not every NHL squad boasts the right mix of skaters to embrace the switch (i.e. teams with fewer than seven NHL-caliber defensemen), and those with the right mix probably wouldn't make the change on a permanent basis. It's not a one-size-fits-all idea aimed to overhaul the hockey playbook.

John Russell / Getty Images

Han is instead suggesting that, for coaches with access to a certain player pool, there may be an alternative formation hiding in plain sight. In fact, the 2F-3D concept is borrowed from the "inverted pyramid" deployment strategy in soccer. Basketball, too, has been reinventing its positional concepts for many years.

Naturally, Han goes back to food to explain the nuances.

"All of this is in the spirit of respecting the ingredients that you have, right?" Han said. "If you have a lot of good forwards and not many good Ds, I don't see the point in (2F-3D). But, if it's the opposite, why not? If you're making burgers and you're out of buns, use a lettuce bun. Make the most of it."

He notes, in terms of X's and O's, adopting the 2F-3D formation wouldn't be a great departure from the norm.

"If you watch hockey now without any preconceived notions of who plays what position, you would think that there's actually three D on the ice at various times in the game," he said.

In one of his posts on the topic, Han breaks down a sequence from the bubbled postseason, in which Tampa Bay Lightning defenseman Ryan McDonagh scored from the top of the circle. On the play, forward Nikita Kucherov assumed the role of the "third defenseman" by lingering high in the offensive zone. He's the so-called "F3" just inside the blue line.

"It is effectively a 2F-3D play, with wingback Mikhail Sergachev pinching down on the right half-wall to win a puck to fullback Nikita Kucherov, who dishes to McDonagh on the opposite wing," Han wrote.

For the majority of NHL teams, including the stacked Lightning, 2F-3D wouldn't make much sense for the top of the lineup. However, bottom-six minutes could be doled out differently if the right personnel - mobile, intelligent, and responsible defensemen - is readily available.

Han's old employers, the Maple Leafs, are an interesting case study - in his words, they're "the perfect testbed." Half of Toronto's payroll is committed to four forwards: Auston Matthews, John Tavares, Mitch Marner, and William Nylander. Those stars should continue to play upward of 20 minutes a night, and the same goes for the likes of Morgan Rielly, Jake Muzzin, and TJ Brodie on the blue line.

But what about those at the other end of the spectrum? How much ice time is there for Rasmus Sandin, Timothy Liljegren, and Mac Hollowell, three young defensemen on the outside looking in for a roster spot on the 2020-21 Maple Leafs? The answer is very little, or none, based on the depth chart.

"For me, the biggest downside that I see in this (2F-3D concept) is simply that having one fewer forward makes you less potent offensively," Han said. "Perhaps it's then a formation you start rolling out within your bottom six."

Han argues, therefore, the team should dress 11 forwards and seven defensemen - or even 10 and eight - and slot in the Sandin-Liljegren-Hollowell trio as the third "pair." Maple Leafs coach Sheldon Keefe could deploy the trio alongside two veteran forwards - maybe Joe Thornton and Jimmy Vesey - in sheltered situations and, for 10 or so minutes per game, the club would be more skilled, more dynamic, and better defensively while utilizing inexpensive pieces.

"That's a really good use-case for me, especially if the top of your forward group is very strong and you don't have a strong bottom six and also have a lot of Ds," Han said. "The perfect fourth-line game is finishing with zero shots for and zero shots against. Because if you tie every one of your fourth-line shifts, then generally speaking you're in good shape for the rest of the game."

Kevin Sousa / Getty Images

For the record, Keefe isn't buying what Han's selling - at least publicly. Han, a former member of Keefe's staff, told Dave Feschuk of the Toronto Star in early November that the likelihood of the Maple Leafs trying out the 2F-3D configuration in 2020-21 is "pretty high." Two weeks later, when asked if it's something he's considering, Keefe said "no." (Though he did go on to share a real-world example of the 2F-3D working at a lower level of hockey.)

"I like to think of myself as someone who will really never say never to anything," Keefe said. "In fact, in my time in (OHL) Sault Ste. Marie, we worked with (2F-3D) at different times when the situation called for it, such as a big defensive-zone faceoff with the goalie out. We felt we had three really strong defenders and put out three defenders and two forwards and had them play more like a penalty-kill situation with three good defenders on the back."

"I remember one time we had a bad injury situation when we were really short on defensemen and we went with four forwards and one defenseman throughout the game and managed that," he added. "So, I've had some experience with that. I think there's enough examples at various levels where I think that has been done, but it's not something I've given a second of thought to for this season's team."

Since going public with the 2F-3D idea, Han has heard from coaches who've used the formation in the past and found varying degrees of success. He said most of them adopted it due to unforeseen circumstances, such as not having enough healthy forwards and plenty of strong defensemen for a single game or adjusting the lineup before facing an overwhelming offensive team.

Icon Sportswire / Getty Images

At its core, the 2F-3D concept is a commentary on the utility of the modern defenseman. Hockey has been accustomed to the faster, high-skill skaters lining up at forward and the heavier skaters who don't move around particularly well taking a spot on the blue line.

"But the game is moving away from that," Han said. "Now you have more and more defensemen who can play the puck and get involved on both sides of the puck."

Defensemen are generally paid less than forwards, too, which is important in an NHL currently experiencing flat revenues.

Roman Josi is the prototypical modern blue-liner. The Nashville Predators captain is an exceptional skater who's responsible defensively and elite in transition. He's a forward-defenseman hybrid who impacts the game in all three zones every single shift. And though there is only one Josi, Han said there are "maybe two-dozen" defensemen finding it difficult to make an NHL roster right now who have a few Josi-like traits and could be deployed in a 2F-3D setup.

Hollowell in Toronto, Calen Addison with the Minnesota Wild, and Ryan Merkley with the San Jose Sharks are three players he mentioned.

"When you change the parameters of the game a little bit, maybe you give these guys an in," Han said. "All of (a) sudden, maybe you have a guy playing on an entry-level (deal) who is an elite offensive contributor from that position that you just (plug in). All you've done is make the job description more favorable to his skill set."

Han didn't pass on a chance to compare hockey to food - and vice versa - to drive home his point.

"It's like anchovies," he said of the 2F-3D configuration. "You hate the idea of it. Then you realize a caesar salad doesn't taste as good without it. Try it in a tomato pasta sauce or on a pizza (and) it just works."

John Matisz is theScore's national hockey writer.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

Germany, Sweden hit with multiple positive tests ahead of WJHC

COVID-19 is making its presence felt just over two weeks ahead of the World Junior Hockey Championship.

Two German players - Lukas Reichel and Nino Kinder - have been ruled out of the tournament after testing positive for the virus, the team announced Tuesday. Reichel was chosen 17th overall by the Chicago Blackhawks at the 2020 draft and collected five points in seven games at last year's tournament.

Additionally, Sweden removed Albin Grewe from its preliminary roster after he became the fourth player to test positive, joining William Wallinder, Karl Henriksson, and William Eklund, according to Hockeysverige's Uffe Bodin. Grewe and Wallinder are both Detroit Red Wings prospects, while Henriksson is a member of the New York Rangers organization.

Tre Kronor's head coach, Tomas Monten, has also contracted COVID-19, per Bodin.

Lastly, IIHF president Rene Fasel has tested positive, although he wasn't planning on traveling to Edmonton for the tournament, reports Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

Report: NHL, NHLPA drop financial talks in push for Jan. 13 start

It appears the NHL and NHLPA are putting their financial differences aside as they try to lock in a plan for the 2020-21 season.

There will be no further discussions regarding financial changes to the memorandum of understanding that outlines the terms of the collective bargaining agreement the sides reached before play returned in August, TSN's Darren Dreger reports.

The NHL's reported attempt at renegotiating the CBA ahead of the 2020-21 season sparked outrage among the players' association. Players originally agreed to defer 10% of their salaries with escrow capped at 20%, but the league asked them to defer 20% of their salaries and push escrow to 25%.

NHL commissioner Gary Bettman refuted the reports and said the portrayal of the negotiations was "unfortunate" and "inaccurate."

On Sunday, the players' association proposed more deferred money but didn't include an increase in escrow, according to Dreger.

Both sides prefer to play a 56-game schedule in 2020-21 and are now aiming to start the season on Jan. 13, two days earlier than the previously known target date, Dreger added.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

Golden Knights’ owner: Proposed Jan. 15 start ‘May slide a week or 2’

Vegas Golden Knights owner Bill Foley is confident the NHL will resume in 2021 but isn't sure it will be by Jan. 15.

A recent report from TSN's Pierre LeBrun indicates the league is moving on from its original Jan. 1 target and a mid-January start is being discussed between the NHL and NHLPA.

"It may not start Jan. 15, it may slide a week or two, but we will be playing hockey and we'll be at T-Mobile," Foley said Monday during an interview with Fox Business.

"But, unfortunately, we may not have fans, which is really sad, especially for our team because we intend on winning the Stanley Cup this year," Foley added.

LeBrun's report also said schedules of 52 or 56 games are being considered. The league is against the idea of staging a season shorter than 48 games - the same number produced during the lockout-abbreviated 2013 campaign.

Negotiations between the league and the Players' Association recently stalled after the NHL asked players to defer 20% of their salaries along with escrow rising to 25%. The new collective bargaining agreement signed in July 2020 stated players will defer 10% of salaries with escrow limited to 20%.

Regardless of a specific start date, the two parties need to reach an agreement soon if they intend to realistically drop the puck at any point in January. The league still needs to finalize divisional realignment on top of picking a schedule, while players outside of North America will likely need to adhere to 14-day quarantine periods before participating in two-week training camps.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

Gretzky rookie card expected to become hockey’s 1st to fetch $1M

A Wayne Gretzky rookie card could set a new record when it's auctioned off later this week.

The mint condition 1979 O-Pee-Chee Gretzky rookie card, which is being sold by Heritage Auctions, is expected to become the first hockey card to break the $1-million mark, according to Kevin McGran of the Toronto Star.

"We're really excited to have the king of hockey cards," Chris Ivy, Heritage's Dallas-based director of sports, told McGran. "The timing is phenomenal as far as the people that are interested in this type of thing and the current market. And Gretzky is the greatest of all time for his sport.

"There are only a handful of cards that have passed the $1-million threshold. This will be the first hockey card to do so."

The card is one of only two 1979 O-Pee-Chee cards to receive a PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) 10 gem mint status.

"When O-Pee-Chee was making these cards in 1979, they didn't lend themselves to be high grade. The paper stock that was used was susceptible to print defects," Ivy explained.

"There are centering issues. The way they cut O-Pee-Chee cards - they used wires (instead of blades). So as those wires dulled, you got those jagged edges. And you can see that jagged edge on this card. Collectors like that look of the jagged edge of the O-Pee-Chee cuts. But that didn't lend itself to high-grade examples either, because there could be chipping, issues in the corners."

Bidding on the card is currently at $662,500 with three days remaining in the auction.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

Sens’ Dorion expecting results during rebuild: ‘It’s time to perform’

Ottawa Senators general manager Pierre Dorion believes his club is trending in the right direction entering the 2020-21 campaign.

And despite being in just the third year of a rebuild, he's ready to see some progress.

"As an organization we’re climbing the charts," Dorion told the Ottawa Sun's Bruce Garrioch. "A lot of the hard work has been done. For us, now, it’s time to perform. We’re at a place where everyone’s on the same page for our immediate success and our future success."

The Senators have finished 30th, 31st, and 30th in the league's standings over the last three seasons. Dorion is now aiming to build a team that can be a perennial contender.

"... We want to have a team, when they drop the puck on the first day of the year, that we know we’re going to be in the playoffs and we know can progress to win Cups," Dorion said. "These things don’t get done overnight. It was always part of the plan, and how we structured the plan, with the way the game has evolved, that we continued this evolution.

"We’re following the right path to have a Cup-contending team year-after-year-after-year as we move along in the rebuild."

Making significant progress this season could be difficult. The NHL is widely expected to adopt an all-Canadian division for one year due to the country's border restrictions, an alignment that would place the Senators in a tough spot.

The six other Canadian teams all qualified for the league's expanded postseason this summer. In a poll The Athletic's Pierre LeBrun conducted of NHL executives, scouts, and coaches from American teams, all 15 of them predicted the Sens would finish last in the all-Canadian division.

Even Senators owner Eugene Melnyk said last month he doesn't like his team's chances in such a format, adding that "this is not our year."

While he seems pessimistic about this season, Melnyk is confident about the future. In October, he said his team will be a "Stanley Cup winner within four years." That may seem bold, but the Sens are set up nicely for the future.

Thomas Chabot and Brady Tkachuk are two key under-24 building blocks who have already proven themselves. The club's farm system is stocked with promising prospects who have received a taste of NHL action, such as Josh Norris, Alex Formenton, Drake Batherson, and Erik Brannstrom. Ottawa also added a trio of 2020 first-rounders to its pipeline in Tim Stuetzle, Jake Sanderson, and Ridly Greig.

Dorion has assembled a stable of veterans for this upcoming season, too, including Matt Murray, Evgenii Dadonov, Austin Watson, Alex Galchenyuk, Erik Gudbranson, and Josh Brown.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

3 more ECHL teams suspend play for 2020-21 season

The Cincinnati Cyclones, Idaho Steelheads, and Kalamazoo Wings will be suspending play for the 2020-21 ECHL season, the league announced Monday.

The three teams join the entire North Division - the Adirondack Thunder, Brampton Beast, Maine Mariners, Newfoundland Growlers, Reading Royals, and Worcester Railers - after each squad also made the decision to opt out.

The Cyclones' NHL affiliate is the Buffalo Sabres, while the Steelheads are connected to the Dallas Stars, and the Wings are in the Vancouver Canucks' system.

Under the league's COVID-19 policy, all players from the three teams are now free agents.

"This decision for our clubs was immensely difficult amidst the ever-changing landscape of the COVID-19 pandemic and the inability to return to play throughout our various jurisdictions,” ECHL commissioner Ryan Crelin said. “We look forward to returning fans and ECHL hockey in these great markets as they shift their focus to the 2021-22 season."

There are now 15 ECHL teams expected to compete during the upcoming campaign set to begin on Dec. 11.

Copyright © 2020 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.